My Experience Of The OCC And Their Understanding Of Risk

I can now reveal that is was the OCC…

The nameless regulator I criticized in my blog on calibration, “Bankers Can’t Avoid Risk by Hiding It,” was the Office of the Comptroller of Currency in Washington.

The OCC has had a lot of negative publicity recently for their less-than-rigorous examination of JPMorgan in the run up to that bank’s multi-billion dollar losses.

Just to recap what I said before, the OCC were unintentionally encouraging banks to hide model risk by requiring calibration when the role of the regulator should be to point out the downside of calibration and instead ask about the stability of the calibrated parameters. Certainly the concept of model risk, and the difference between hiding risk and hedging it, seemed beyond them. So it didn’t come as a surprise to me that the difference between hedging and speculation also proved too much for their very theoretical brains.

To add a bit of balance here, my experience of the OCC was not dissimilar to my experiences of many quant teams in banks. By this I mean that they love to talk mathematics but struggle to talk markets. When you’ve had a quant education that’s too academic then all you’ve seen is complete markets and risk neutrality, so it’s almost understandable that you don’t appreciate model risk. It doesn’t exist in complete markets! And of course in the risk-neutral world you pretend as if everything earns the same rate of return and risk has no value!

It’s all beginning to make sense!

Part of the solution is more robust education and better critical thinking.

But the cynic in me thinks that if regulators were better educated in the ‘practice’ of banking then there’d be less trading, smaller bonuses and fewer donations to political parties.

P

Related Posts

Bankers Can’t Avoid Risk by Hiding It (A version of this was first published on Bloomberg.com on May 24, 2011.) One of the supposed silver linings of our recent economic disaster was th...
FSA: It’s Worse Than I Feared Remember my blog about Magicians and Mathematicians in which I complained about the lack of imagination in risk management? If you don't, then please ...
Where Do You Keep Your Offshore Money? Where do you keep your offshore money? The media is all upset about celebs, politicians, etc. having money in various offshore places, in order to ...
Bloomberg View Columnist Barry Ritholtz Interviews... Listen to Barry Ritholtz interview Paul Wilmott about quantitative finance, mathematical modelling, reputational risk, Tom Cruise, JK Rowling, Billy J...
Boris Johnson, Yanis Varoufakis And Sir Vince Cabl... Boris Johnson, Yanis Varoufakis and Sir Vince Cable all have something in common…. All three have been in the news lately with their interpretation...
Webcast – Paul Wilmott On “The Money F... Paul recently gave a talk in downtown Manhattan about his new book, co-authored with David Orrell, The Money Formula. Other topics get dragged in alon...
Jeremy Corbyn: My Part In His Ascent First, disclosure: I am rather right wing, from the school of "take some of my income in taxes but otherwise leave me alone, please." And as a general...
Product Risk Classification What is the PRC? The product risk classification (PRC) is a risk indicator that is based on quantitative models. It allows us to compare the fi...

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply