FSA: It’s Worse Than I Feared

Remember my blog about Magicians and Mathematicians in which I complained about the lack of imagination in risk management? If you don’t, then please take a look otherwise the rest of this blog won’t make any sense to you at all!


Well, I just had a very frightening experience at a conference. I used the magician example to get the audience to open up to the idea of thinking beyond the simple mathematics. I started with “What is the probability of…,” and received the usual “One in 52” reply. Then the location (the magic show) was pointed out, and people changed their answer to 100%. Except that some people didn’t. There were three people in the audience of maybe 100 who stuck to their original 1/52 answer and refused to budge.

So far so typical.

Now the frightening bit. The audience consisted almost entirely of actuaries. (That’s not the frightening bit!) Except for three people from the FSA. And two of those were ones who insisted on the ‘math’ answer 1/52. (That’s the bit that scared me!)

One of them explained his reasoning. I cannot remember the details, it was quite lengthy, but the essence was that “The answer should have been one in 52 except that the magician was tricking us and so really we should ignore this factor…” (I apologise if I have got this wrong, but from the reaction of the audience I don’t think I have!)

Now forgive me but isn’t the FSA supposed to be operating in the real world in which things are just not about pure mathematics? A world in which risk managers hide risk, moral hazard is rife and magicians do, er, magic. Isn’t that sort of the entire point? If it was all about the maths then we wouldn’t have the FSA, we’d use someone like the EdExcel examiners to give banks marks out of a hundred at the end of term.

P

Total Views: 125 ,

Related Posts

At Last: Education, Education, Education Theresa May wants to bring back grammar schools. According to one poll 60% of the British public agree with this idea. If I'd been asked I would have ...
“Algo My Way, You Go Your Way” My upcoming talk at the Quant Insights conference, 14th October, London, will be "Algo My Way, You Go Your Way - Four Decades in Business." More detai...
All Mod Cons For the UK and wilmott.com it's that once-in-a-generation moment. A new bathroom? No! While Mark Carney performs his fine balancing act of talki...
Sir Bob Geldof, We Who Are About To Thrive Salute ... A big, big thank you from those of us who wanted out of the EU to: Lord Stuart Rose, leader of the Remain camp, for his timely confession Da...
How I Successfully Forecast The Result Of The EU R... Gosh, this is embarrassing. I seem to have done the double. This is a sequel to my blog from last year How I Successfully Forecast The Results Of T...
A Proper Analysis Of The EU Referendum Polls I've been following the polling with obsessive interest. And finding the analysis somewhat feeble. I'm going to very quickly address the topic of poll...
Things That Haven’t Been Said About The EU R... Debate? Debate?? They don’t know the meaning of debate! The two sides have both in their own ways been like broken records. The same old arguments ...
Why I And All My Rich Pals Are Voting To Stay In T... I’m relatively rich. I can afford private healthcare. I don’t have to worry about long waiting lists for operations or the impossibility of getting...